Copyright laws have always been difficult terrain for me to navigate. Probably because I have never researched it for myself and have relied on our school's TRT or librarian to help children site their sources. However, because students are now encouraged to share their work with a larger audience, understanding copyright guidelines has become crucial to educators.
After reading Copyright Clarity, I have learned just how lack of understanding on this topic can squash creativity in projects and actually prevent teachers and students from sharing their work. Teachers are fearful of getting reprimanded by their administrators or are concerned about receiving the dreaded cease and desist letter. I know first hand the hesitation teachers feel when contemplating if something about the students' projects would raise a red flag concerning copyright violation.
In my opinion, this book is a keeper. It will go to school with me and remain close at hand as I navigate project based learning and sharing work to a larger audience. I feel more confident in my skills to make a good judgement on whether resources the students choose are free to use how the student has decided to incorporate them in their work. We, as teachers, need to consider several factors to determine if fair use applies. According to this book, we need to take into consideration, the purpose of the use, the nature of the work, the amount used, and the market impact.
Transformativeness is also a component we must use in ethical decision making. Is the copyrighted work used in a different way and geared toward a different audience than the original audience? In education, most students' work would meet this criteria because they are so creative and their project is in response to a teacher's assignment. Unless the student is duplicating another student's assignment, transformativeness is most likely present.
While working with my students on their various projects, I plan on using these guiding factors in determining if their work if free from any copyrighted concerns so that we all feel confident in sharing their work with the public. Our desire in the field of education is to see our students as designers and to avoid limiting their creativity. Understanding copyright will definitely help unleash the potential for the student to create and share unique, inspiring projects.
Transformativeness was the component that helped me understand the idea of fair use the best as well. I like how you related it back to our design principle of students as designers. It’s important to rely the information of fair use to our students as they grow as learners to inspire them to be designers and not stifle their creativity. I think a lot of our students want to create new things and not plagiarize; however, when students feel like they can’t use anything without getting into “trouble,” they become frustrated and might be more willing to take the risk of copying material than have the difficult task of coming up with a completely new product.
ReplyDeleteI agree, this book is a book that will be kept close by for years to come. Like you said, with the focus on PBL and sharing projects with a larger audience it is important as teachers to know what is considered fair use, and what is violating copyright. I also want to share what I learned with my colleagues because, I bet most if not all of them have been misinformed about copyright law and fair use, just as I believe we all were.
ReplyDeleteYou're so right that this will help us better support our students as they share their work with a larger audience! I'm happy to hear this has made you more comfortable with that; I definitely feel it has made me more mindful of the example I set to my students and the conversations I have with them. What I'm still struggling with is how do we get them to internalize these ideas? It's enough of a struggle for me to wrestle with it--I'm still not quite sure how to teach them to be judges of fair use.
ReplyDelete