Sunday, September 25, 2016

The Third Design Principle

The Third Design Principle:

The Knowledge Principle
Good learning designs recognize concepts as tools, situate those concepts in the context of their use reflecting authentic activity, conceptual tool, and culture, and analyze content for generalizable knowledge.

After leaving class Wednesday night, I had a better understanding of the four articles we had read during the week. However, when I sat down to write this blog, I found I needed to reread them. Then, when I cut and pasted the third design principle on my word document, it all became clear and fit together.

The third design principle basically states that it isn’t enough to have your students gain a basic understanding of the content. They need to be engaging in authentic activities, gaining an understanding of how this knowledge fits into their particular culture, and finally they need to be able to be able to apply this knowledge when exposed to different or related examples. In other words, they can generalize their new found knowledge rather than simply regurgitate basic facts and dates.

The articles we read helped to give teachers a guideline of how to accomplish this important principle. If I were to meld the articles together, one of the important concepts was to have the children solve an authentic problem. They should accomplish this through building activities, constructing activities, and then they must be given an opportunity to share their results. All of these ways of gaining knowledge should tie into growing students who can contribute to their communities.

Another concept presented in the articles was the importance of teachers modeling thought processes while students are gaining knowledge. Students need to be shown how to work through a problem using different thought processes. We can become practitioners in the field to give the kids a glimpse into how people who work in a particular domain work through a situation.

The importance of scaffolding technology was another point discussed. If we don’t put thought into what the kids do and do not know, the technology component can quickly become a source of frustration rather than a way in which children can become more engaged or proficient with software they will be expected to know when they enter the workforce down the road.


Relevance. That is the one word I would use if I had to sum up the third design principle. I plan on incorporating more learning activities in my lessons which will provoke thought and problem solving after the students have gained a basic understanding through textbook, films and discussions. This goal will take time and will require tweaking from year to year. A different group of students each year brings different background knowledge and cultures with which to work. Baby steps…..

Saturday, September 17, 2016

The Second Design Principle.....

"Good learning designs prepare learners to meet community needs by linking living and learning to the PICKLE (problem-solving, information using, community participation, knowledgeable, literate, ethical decision-making).  Teachers may need an apple a day, but learners need a pickle!"

After reading and discussing The Saber-Tooth Curriculum, it seems to me that the when New Fist said, "If I could only get those children to do the things that would give more and better, food, shelter, clothing, and security....I would be helping this tribe to have a better life.", he had a reasonable educational goal to meet the community needs. He was linking living and learning to many components of the PICKLE. When the kids were learning skills like fish grabbing, they were problem solving for the community. The students were using information from their teacher and participating in the community. The children were actually having an authentic learning experience in the beginning.

Somewhere along the way, the author suggests education lost its purpose. This loss of focus seemed to occur when fish net making became necessary and there was resistance by "the old men". The conditions changed in that society and "the old men" did not see the vision of the "radicals". 

The author also pokes fun at what I will call fake authentic learning. The principal at the Real-Tiger school caged tigers so kids could still learn to wave fire at them which no longer was even a skill that helped their society. 

Even funnier was when the youth were moving rocks as a recreation activity because there was no work in the tribe to be done. Although they pleaded to work and create wealth and happiness for the tribe, the youths' ideas were shut down.

During my life, I have witnessed similar issues that this author explored so many years ago.
The leaders in the education field are slow to change or when they do make changes, teachers feel they have no say in the chosen program. Sometimes, we are even given scripts to read which diminishes our capacity to teach the students how, as professionals, we know works.

If I have learned anything, I have learned that eventually theories of good education circle back. Right now, I feel we are beginning to see glimpses of getting back to crucial components of education that will help our students to become real contributors. We are now focusing on problem solving, working on real world problems in the world, and encouraging the community members to join in on the learning. There is also a commitment to giving our students the opportunity to collaborate and communicate while using technology. 

With the exception of one component of a very scripted reading program we are putting in place, I feel hopeful that our young people will be receiving a practical and engaging education. It will be interesting to see what happens.....

Saturday, September 10, 2016


“They develop a new swagger, but also a tenacity that they didn’t have. And that is priceless.” https://ww2.kqed.org/mindshift/2012/10/01/recasting-teachers-and-students-as-designers/

Pilloton, who gave a compelling TED talk about her work in North Carolina, said that in her experience working with youth both urban and rural, there is a common thread – the power of design to be a transformative personal learning experience.
They were inspired by the idea of teachers thinking of themselves as designers, leaders of a collaborative process of identifying learning objectives and crafting an experience that engages students in achieving those objectives.

Wow! I have to admit that after the first face to face class session, my mind was boggled. I am a nuts and bolts sort of person who looks at the objectives and works on engaging the students in the curriculum so they can understand and hopefully make a connection to, why do we have to learn this in the first place. I do integrate technology and spend quite a bit of time researching ways to do this. My strength, as a teacher, lies in establishing the rapport with kids and creating an atmosphere of acceptance and encouragement in the classroom, so kids feel comfortable taking risks. I do not see myself as a designer. This class and program is definitely going to encourage me to shift my thinking and boost my skills as a classroom teacher/designer.

Because I was so unfamiliar with this concept of a teacher being a designer, I researched scholarly articles and various education web sites to better understand this philosophy. I began to get excited about the possibility of growing as a designer. The project based learning that the county is encouraging ties in perfectly. If I am designer, my kids will have me as a role model to become designers in their own right. I have learned that designing is not the same as planning. I look at it as the final outcome I would want from the students. However, it is key to realize their fulfillment of my design may not be what I envisioned. I could be even better!

Where I get stuck is managing the time involved with implementing this kind of mind shift. So far, it appears that this kind of learning will take more time to implement in the classroom. The advantages are obvious; the perceived barriers have to be knocked down. Secondly, I know that I have difficulty in managing behaviors in the classroom where kids are collaborating and all working on something different. I am getting better at this, but it is definitely an area where there is opportunity for growth!

I am envisioning using this principle while figuring out how to creatively allow the students to acquire the knowledge they need but in a new way. There are at least two project based learning activities the fourth grade team is in the process of planning for this year. My goal is to use a design philosophy rather than a planning mentality. Letting loose of the reigns is going to be key.

The two quotes listed above are giving me inspiration and tenacity to put in the work to become a designer in the classroom. Why? I want to give my kids that swagger and empower them to become designers and feel they have the capability to use their imagination and not feel confined and limited to certain possibilities.