After reading this article, I have been introduced to technological affordances such as:
- media (text, images, audio, and video ability)
- spatial (ability to resize and move element)
- temporal (accessibility)
- navigation (ability to link and browse to other sections)
- emphasis (ability to highlight or focus)
- synthesis (ability for mixed media use)
- access-control (described as share-ability)
Although technical affordances, usability, aesthetics, and reliability appear to take a backseat to the previous considerations because they deal with usability rather than utility, they also need to be contemplated when making design decisions.
How does this apply in my classroom? I need to flip my thinking and consistently begin with the learning goal and proceed from there using an affordance analysis template to pick the best technology tool that matches my goal. When a new technology captures my interest, I will need to resist trying to make it work for a project. Instead, I need to try it out myself and really evaluate its match to our target before launching its use class wide which could result in a total flop of a lesson.
No points made in this article should have been surprising to us as teachers; however, it provided a valuable opportunity for us to have a gentle reminder. Does this enticing technology really match our learning goal?
You're right, no points should have come as a surprise to us. I know when I was in my undergrad, backwards design was a big push for us: think about what you want your students to know at the end of the lesson/unit and how you are going to evaluate them and then build your lessons from there. Affordance analysis really fits in nicely with that. Think about the learning goals first to design which technology will best support those goals.
ReplyDeleteI agree that the points made in the article were not a surprise. When doing an affordance analysis, I definitely find it "easier" to think of the learning goal first and go from there; however, I remember Priscilla saying we can also start at the technology and work to the learning goal. This would for sure take some getting used to--I think it's our nature to start with the learning goal because it's kind of important to know what we're trying to teach! Haha. When I read your comment on Alissa's post about the Google app, it got me thinking about starting with the technology and seeing if it fits with a learning goal you teach your 4th graders. Looking forward to hearing about how that technology works!!
ReplyDeleteI am sad to admit that I was as surprised as I was while reading the affordance article. It just makes sense to step back and analyzing the affordances of a technology first. I too used to gravitate towards the newest, and “greatest” technology. I will now be focusing on the learning goal first, and evaluating its utility and usability, along with identifying constraints. The only challenge now is, to get my team on board with me.
ReplyDeleteI have definitely been guilty of starting with the technology too! And, as you said, sometimes the lesson flopped because of that approach. I agree with Alissa that this fits in perfectly with backward design--starting with the end goal in mind. I also agree with you that the concepts that take a backseat in this conversation (usability, aesthetics, and reliability) should still be factors that are considered when evaluating a technology. Recently, I got so frustrated trying to get a certain program to work for my students consistently and easily, that I have abandoned it for another similar program that is much more user-friendly and reliable.
ReplyDelete