Saturday, September 17, 2016

The Second Design Principle.....

"Good learning designs prepare learners to meet community needs by linking living and learning to the PICKLE (problem-solving, information using, community participation, knowledgeable, literate, ethical decision-making).  Teachers may need an apple a day, but learners need a pickle!"

After reading and discussing The Saber-Tooth Curriculum, it seems to me that the when New Fist said, "If I could only get those children to do the things that would give more and better, food, shelter, clothing, and security....I would be helping this tribe to have a better life.", he had a reasonable educational goal to meet the community needs. He was linking living and learning to many components of the PICKLE. When the kids were learning skills like fish grabbing, they were problem solving for the community. The students were using information from their teacher and participating in the community. The children were actually having an authentic learning experience in the beginning.

Somewhere along the way, the author suggests education lost its purpose. This loss of focus seemed to occur when fish net making became necessary and there was resistance by "the old men". The conditions changed in that society and "the old men" did not see the vision of the "radicals". 

The author also pokes fun at what I will call fake authentic learning. The principal at the Real-Tiger school caged tigers so kids could still learn to wave fire at them which no longer was even a skill that helped their society. 

Even funnier was when the youth were moving rocks as a recreation activity because there was no work in the tribe to be done. Although they pleaded to work and create wealth and happiness for the tribe, the youths' ideas were shut down.

During my life, I have witnessed similar issues that this author explored so many years ago.
The leaders in the education field are slow to change or when they do make changes, teachers feel they have no say in the chosen program. Sometimes, we are even given scripts to read which diminishes our capacity to teach the students how, as professionals, we know works.

If I have learned anything, I have learned that eventually theories of good education circle back. Right now, I feel we are beginning to see glimpses of getting back to crucial components of education that will help our students to become real contributors. We are now focusing on problem solving, working on real world problems in the world, and encouraging the community members to join in on the learning. There is also a commitment to giving our students the opportunity to collaborate and communicate while using technology. 

With the exception of one component of a very scripted reading program we are putting in place, I feel hopeful that our young people will be receiving a practical and engaging education. It will be interesting to see what happens.....

5 comments:

  1. Hi Jen,

    I am only in my 6th year of teaching. So, In my teacher education courses and practices were unfortunately primarily based in those horribly scripted programs. However, while I am still early in my career I have been a part of my mom's classroom in various ways my entire life, and she just retired after 38 years of teaching. She has always told me how education policy goes in phases. I can remember a time watching her teach with authentic engaging activities. It is why I always wanted to be a teacher. The system we have now is not what I signed up for. However, like you said I am starting to see signs of change. Especially, with my county's new focus on PBL. I am hopeful for what the future has in store.

    ReplyDelete
  2. So true that educational policy is starting to trend towards more authenticity and problem solving (thank goodness).
    I assume you're talking about Pathways in your comment on reading - I'm curious which part you feel is scripted and how the 3-5 setup differs from K-2. I'm struggling with some of the components and concepts and how I can adapt Pathways to fit better with our design principles.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Alissa...the scripted part are our minilessons. We are finding them to be a little awkward and they aren't tying into our sols we are responsible for. We are encouraged to use the same language and it feels a little strange to us. For instance, "readers, from this day forward, I expect you to...."

    ReplyDelete
  4. You make some really good points from the Sabertooth Curriculum Jen! I agree that we are beginning to see glimpses of hope in our educational system but it scares me that they are just that--glimpses. I feel like we do all of these initiatives like OTTW, PBL, LoudounCreates, etc and that they are just that...campaigns, or even worse for many, another requirement or box to check off. I know it will take time and baby steps, but it just scares me that we won't actually get to a place in our education system where OTTW is the way we teach everything instead of just one isolated project that we feel we have to complete to satisfy the county.

    ReplyDelete
  5. You bring up a great point about educational policy, Jen! I have a friend who recently graduated from a master's program in educational policy. Her and I happened to get into a debate about Common Core, and boy, did we have differing opinions! Differing opinions are important and vital in any culture, but it made me think--is this why the field of education goes in these circles you spoke of? Are students going to school for educational policy, etc. learning something different than teachers in terms of how to look at education and what students in school need to know to be successful citizens? Sometimes when a person is out of the classroom for years, they lose sight of what a student and teacher's day-to-day is like. I'm certainly not putting the blame squarely on educational policy makers, but I do wonder if we don't collaborate as an educational culture quite like we should to help promote things like PICKLE into all aspects of schooling.

    ReplyDelete